Welcome to Everything Croton, a collection of all things Croton-on-Hudson: our history, our homes, our issues, our businesses, our schools, our houses of worship --- in short, EVERYTHING CROTON.
FROM THE GAZETTE 11/19-11/25
To the editor:
Most of us were taught as children to apologize when we have wronged someone. But what if the offending party does not believe they have anything to apologize for? That is the situation with the village’s IDEA committee.
Like many of you, my parents required me to apologize regardless. It was a matter of politeness and empathy. But when someone feels so strongly that they don’t care about the hurt they cause, perhaps an insincere apology is not a paramount concern. Maybe we should address the underlying issue.
We like to believe the best in people, which can lead us to dismiss hurtful or illegal behavior as uncharacteristically aberrant. When IDEA first targeted the speech of a local journalist, our Village Manager gave a tortured legalistic distinction which even he must have thought was nonsense.
The IDEA members then expanded the scope of their hostility to a bunch of village residents and businesses.
The ever-diplomatic trustee Nachtaler suggested that bias training “should be offered for residents operating at the head of village diversity work.” The Village Manager continued to avoid the underlying issue by telling us this was a matter of FOIL disclosure violations. Trustee Slippen cut to the heart of the problem: “The institution that made the errors should not be left to quietly correct itself… The Board needs to look honestly at what went wrong, why, and what will keep it from happening again” (Croton Chronicle, Oct 23 2026).
Michael Balter was the original target of IDEA. He says members of The Croton Landing “instigated” the controversy.
Let us be clear: the members of IDEA instigated this controversy. Nobody else.
Posting source recordings and documents on The Croton Landing is no different from the Chronicle posting source material. I have never read The Croton Landing, but I applaud anyone who exposes bad behavior by members of government—including village committees.
Mr. Balter says that some residents are “sworn enemies of the values the IDEA Committee stands for” (Croton Chronicle, Oct 9 2026). He further distinguishes the “core values” of IDEA; implying that the controversy comes from IDEA acting on non-core values. It is this insight which is relevant to resolution.
I steer clear of the Facebook cesspool because I don’t particularly care who is a sworn enemy of anyone else. I do not know what is in the mind of members of IDEA, let alone the rest of the village. I don’t think it is necessary to go down that path in order to move forward.
I do think we must ask precisely what “values” are being expressed. More importantly, we need to discuss the nexus between those “core values” and the instant controversy.
As a subsidiary entity of the State of New York, the Village of Croton has mandatory constraints imposed by law, including the state and federal constitutions. “Inclusion” is in the eye of the beholder, and Croton has never been inclusive of a vast swath of residents—look for example at the political composition of village committees. “Diversity” is another feel-good label whose legality is fact-dependent. The village cannot discriminate, which renders “Equity” problematic if it were ever enforced.
“Accessibility” is fairly clear cut, with voluminous statutory and regulatory basis starting with ADA Title II.
Croton was incorporated in 1898. The DEI committee was established in 2018. Were those 120 years a dark time of hatred and exclusion?
Certainly one might make the argument for dark days during the time of Mayor Bogardus or Schmidt: their failure to be members of the One True Party renders them suspect. But what about the tenure of Mayor Elliott? If that was a time of bigotry and discrimination, why did we name a street after him?
What about Mayor Wiegman—was hatred and intolerance rampant during his administration? He was re-elected multiple times as Trustee and Mayor, so if his administration was discriminatory it says something about us voters.
If the olden days were not ones of municipally-sanctioned bigotry (at least when Dems were in office), what precisely has changed in the last 8 years?
This gets us to the “core” mission of IDEA. Let us focus on the actions taken by IDEA. The primary activity of the committee is to set a hierarchy and assess a dollar value to each group deemed worthy of governmental recognition: Are you a member of the “trans” group? Where did your ancestors come from?
Depending on certain factors (many of them immutable characteristics) you will either be celebrated at taxpayer expense, or you will not.
I am not opposed to remembering history, including times when our country has not lived up to the principles of our Constitution. I do not oppose in principle the village recognizing the injustices suffered by those in the past, and it is appropriate that village events call upon us to be better. But we need to be honest with ourselves, both individually and in our collective capacity as residents of this village. Our government will pay for a celebration serving burritos but not a celebration serving babka.
There are reasons why you might say that one ethnic group or persons of a particular sexual orientation are more deserving than others. Nothing beats a babka, but perhaps it is not an appropriate purchase using tax money.
Another uncomfortable reality: When the criteria is based on past discrimination against certain groups, there is an implicit stereotyping in having particular living residents as exemplars of real people long deceased.
Determination of the official Village of Croton celebratory hierarchy may properly be based on valid historic documentation. Those reasons may be based on discrimination against living persons, ancestors, or complete strangers long deceased.
Here in Croton we have collectively decided that we will celebrate particular groups deemed worthy by virtue of historical discrimination. Determination of who is to be celebrated needs to be done with some sensitivity. It should not be based on the judgment of a handful of people who are mean-spirited, divisive, and lacking in humility.
--Paul Steinberg, Croton-on-Hudson

No comments:
Post a Comment